Canada Faces Backlash Over Mass Immigration Application Cancellations Amid 2.2 Million Backlog

In June, the Canadian government introduced Bill C-2, better known as the “Strong Borders Act.” While it was presented as a measure to strengthen border security, the proposed law is stirring heated debate in Parliament and beyond.

Critics argue that behind the rhetoric of efficiency lies a troubling shift: the bill would give Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) broad authority to suspend or cancel thousands of applications at once. This raises concerns about fairness, predictability, and even the very identity of Canada’s immigration system.

📌 Where Things Stand

As of September 17, Bill C-2 is in its second reading in the House of Commons, with marathon debates taking place the day before. The Conservative Party has voiced support, boosting the likelihood of passage.

But the pushback is strong: over 300 organizations are demanding its withdrawal. Civil society warns of refugee rights violations, while legal experts caution that procedural justice could collapse. The message is clear: this isn’t just about border control—it’s about the future of Canada’s immigration framework.

⚖️ The Backdrop: A Massive Backlog

At the heart of this bill is Canada’s immigration backlog crisis.

• As of July 31, 2025, more than 2.2 million applications remain in limbo.

• That includes 890,000 permanent residence files and 1.07 million temporary residence files.

• Worse, over half of PR applications and 38% of temporary applications are already past the legal processing deadline.

Many applicants have been waiting years, often in unstable legal or financial situations. COVID-19 extensions bought some time, but without deeper reforms, the system hit breaking point.

🛑 Why the Bill Is Controversial

Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree has defended the bill, citing COVID-era challenges when Canada lacked tools to revoke temporary permits.

But the sticking point is the bill’s “public interest” clause. It sets no clear criteria, effectively handing IRCC a blank check to cancel or freeze applications. Lawyers warn that political winds—or social pressure—could drive sweeping cancellations.

We’ve seen this before: in 2012, the Harper government wiped out all skilled worker applications filed before 2008. Courts upheld the move, setting a precedent critics fear could repeat itself.

🎯 Who Could Be Most Affected?

Analysts believe the government will first target programs with extreme delays or low perceived economic benefit:

• Start-Up Visa: Average processing is 53 months, making it a prime candidate.

• Self-Employed Program: Already closed to new intake until 2027, and possibly on the chopping block.

• Low-Wage Temporary Workers: Many cycle through short permits; under Bill C-2, they could lose status overnight.

• Refugee Sponsorships: Long waits could prompt caps or mass cancellations under a “system reset.”

The consequences? Families, students, and workers could suddenly lose legal status, exposing them to deportation, detention, and disruption of entire livelihoods.

🌍 Canada’s Reputation at Stake

For decades, Canada has been praised as one of the world’s most attractive immigration destinations, thanks to transparent processes and reliable settlement pathways.

Supporters say Bill C-2 will clear the backlog and redirect resources to high-value immigrants. Opponents warn it will create uncertainty, inequality, and reputational damage in the global talent race.

The real test lies ahead: will the bill’s “public interest” clause be narrowed and checked during committee review? Refugees, low-wage workers, and entrepreneurs will be the first to feel its impact—and their experiences will define how Canada is judged on the world stage.

💡 What Applicants Should Do

If you’re in the process of immigrating to Canada, here are some strategic steps to consider:

• Monitor Bill C-2 closely and follow its progress through Parliament.

• Diversify your options—avoid relying on a single program if possible.

• Seek professional advice to understand your legal rights.

• Prepare backup plans, including alternative pathways or countries, if delays or cancellations occur.

🚨 Final Thoughts

Bill C-2 is more than a bureaucratic fix—it’s a turning point for Canadian immigration. Whether it passes, gets amended, or is scrapped, the outcome will reshape how Canada balances efficiency with fairness.

For applicants, this is a moment to stay alert, plan ahead, and protect your interests. For Canada, it’s a chance to decide whether efficiency should come at the cost of the values that built its immigration system in the first place.

Book a consultation now!

Canada Faces Backlash Over Mass Immigration Application Cancellations Amid 2.2 Million Backlog